good pizza. good people. great memories.

ALWAYS USE THE FINEST INGREDIENTS AVAILABLE, TREAT YOUR CUSTOMERS AND EMPLOYEES LIKE FAMILY AND ALWAYS GIVE BACK TO THE COMMUNITY.

Award winning.

Pizza Cottage is among the nation’s best-performing pizzerias and ranked in PIZZA TODAY® Magazine’s Hot 100 List. We have also been named the best pizza in Licking County. Thank you for supporting Pizza Cottage!

giving back.

Giving back is a core value of our business. We love helping our community raise money for their organizations through Eat Pizza. Raise Dough. We are also proud to sponsor business and charitable events as well as sports teams in the communities we serve.

GROWING.

From a small coney shop in Carroll, Ohio to ten locations throughout the state, we are continuing to grow our footprint so that everyone can always enjoy the best tastes of Pizza Cottage.

Please note, due to significant price increases for commodities as well as increased labor and operational costs, our company has decided to implement a 3% surcharge instead of increasing menu prices. This is not a sales tax. We appreciate your understanding as we work to find ways to continue to compete and provide exceptional service in today’s current environment. If you have any questions or concerns, we encourage you to contact us at info@pizza-cottage.com.

WHY PEOPLE LOVE PIZZA COTTAGE…

“First time at Pizza Cottage (have seen food trucks) but never had it. BEST CAULIFLOWER PIZZA around and ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS wings! (wayyyy better than other chicken restaurants!). Staff was really busy but very helpful and friendly! Definitely recommend!”

— elaine l.

“My experience today at Pizza Cottage was tremendous like always. My waitress was very attentive and upbeat and I appreciate all of the service. They have great food and definitely a recommended place to gather with family and friends.”

— MARISA M.

“We drive an hour and a half just to eat here. Or when we are "home" we hit the Buckeye Lake location. My all time favorite! Everyone who knows me knows this. BLT pizza, PLT sub, and everything in between. Always yummy and wonderful service!”