It all started in 1972 when…

Jack and Yvonne Gorham converted a small coney shop in Carroll, Ohio into the first Pizza Cottage. Over the years their son Kevin grew the business into what it is today by using the principles he learned from his parents: always use the finest ingredients available, treat your customers and employees like family and always give back to the community.

For years the Pizza Cottage in Buckeye Lake, Ohio attracted customers from all over Central Ohio. In 2007 Pizza Cottage returned to Lancaster, Ohio and continued the tradition of delivering the same great taste and service that has made Pizza Cottage famous!

  • In 2008 the Pizza Cottage opened a location in Newark, Ohio at 969 Mount Vernon Road. This location featured a large patio for outdoor dining and a drive-up window.

  • Pizza Cottage opened its fourth location in Pickerington, Ohio in 2009. The Pickerington location’s outdoor patio was expanded to seat 100 people.

  • Our fifth Pizza Cottage location opened on November 1, 2012, in Zanesville, Ohio.

  • Pizza Cottage returned to Circleville, Ohio with its sixth location in June 2013. The Pizza Cottage was in Circleville from 1983 to 1993 and we were so thrilled to be able to bring it back to the area.